I’m currently re-reading one of my favourite books, Choke by Chuck Paluhniuk, and something the protagonist’s mother said struck me as incredibly salient. Looking back on her life, she remarks, "I fought against everything, but more and more I worry that I was never for anything... Griping isn't the same as creating something. Rebelling isn't rebuilding. Ridiculing isn't replacing... We've spent so much time judging what other people created that we've created very, very little of our own."
It made me think about the shift I’ve noticed in culture and entertainment products: the shift from cultural production to cultural aggregation. Take pinterest for example - we can spend hours and hours re-pinning picturesque portraits of our ideal hair/dinner/evening, yet the whole time we're only collecting substitutes for real experiences. What's more, some of us (read: me) develop a sense of pride in having, say, 76 followers on our Harry Potter pinboard, but was it really us who created the DIY crochet Voldemort keychain or brewed the home-made Butter Beer? I look at my humour pinboard and think to myself, Damn I'm hysterical. But I didn't come up with those memes and I didn't take those funny photographs. I was just fortunate enough to stumble upon them and possess enough IQ points to get the joke.
We're accumulating instead of creating, teased by the promise of building an experience in the future. I'll pin this now and do it later.
The idea of acquiring something and taking credit for its discovery has a lot to do with taste. Build a popular 8tracks playlist and you instantaneously feel valorized, your superior musical proclivities affirmed. But who composed the music? Who spent hours learning music, practicing and writing the piece? And who took a few minutes to search their music collection and upload it to the web?
I'm guilty of the same thing. My radio show is my baby and and I take pride in what I broadcast. When someone calls in and says "I love what you're playing," I'm on cloud nine for the rest of the day. But I need to recognize that I was just lucky enough to stumble upon this music, and all the credit really goes to the artist. I've collected it and shared it, but I haven't composed it.
And when I don't like something, I criticize but never create. I'll ridicule but never re-mix (not that I'd know how to re-mix Flo Rida's Whistle into a feminist anthem, but it wouldn't hurt to try).
That being said, I'm going to try to create more. Maybe not pinworthy creations, but it wouldn't hurt to pick up my guitar and re-learn the chords to Changes by Stars. Or sit down and try my hand at poetry again. Even camping out at my local library for an afternoon until I've handwritten letters to my friends will have meant I spent hours creating instead of watching this YouTube video... for the 12th time.
High-fives and heatwaves,